The lowest possible rate is how many define a good mortgage. But that’s like judging the “best car” by the one with the lowest monthly payment.
Anyone who’s had to cough up a mortgage penalty or deal with refinance limitations can vouch for one thing: Mortgage restrictions can easily outweigh small (e.g., 0.10 to 0.15 percentage point) differences in interest rates.
It’s tough to predict your refinance needs three or four years out. Statistics show that well over half of Canadians with a mortgage renegotiate before their term is up. And the average five-year borrower changes their mortgage every three-and-a-half years.
That’s why it often pays to trade a slightly lower rate for more flexibility, unless you know you won’t change your mortgage during its term. A cheap rate can certainly save hundreds of dollars up front. Just be sure it doesn’t cost thousands after closing.
On that note, here’s a list of questions to ask your mortgage expert of choice. Check the boxes one by one as you talk with your adviser. With a little effort, this list will help you snare the most feature-rich mortgage possible, at a rate that’s better than average.
Download the PDF version of this checklist.
Here’s what you need to consider
- The rate
- Extra payments
- Variable-rate mortgages
- Other features
- Extra costs
1. Is the rate you’re quoting me the lowest I can possibly get, given my qualifications and mortgage preferences?
2. If I find a lower rate for a similar product elsewhere, will you match it?
3. How many other lenders did you check when shopping around my mortgage? Which major banks and credit unions did you not check?
- These questions apply to brokers because bankers and credit union reps generally don’t shop around for you.
- RateSpy.com is a tool I created to help mortgage shoppers benchmark the competitiveness of their rate. If you’re within 0.10 per cent to 0.15 per cent of the lowest rates on this site (for the term you’ve selected), you’re in good shape. Just be sure to compare apples to apples because the cheapest rates are often for no frills mortgages with potentially costly restrictions.
4. How long will the lender hold my rate, once I apply?
- The best rates often come with only 30-45 day rate hold periods (aka. “quick close rates”).
5. If I get approved and rates drop, how will I know? Will the lender automatically adjust my rate lower? Will I get the lender’s very best promotional rates if its rates fall?
6. Can I get a pre-approval at this rate?
- Pre-approvals often come with rate premiums.
7. Do you offer fully discounted rates up front at renewal? Or do you send me an inflated rate in a renewal letter and hope I sign it?
8. How much extra can I prepay each year without penalty?
- Standard “closed” mortgages offer annual “lump-sum” prepayment options ranging from 10 to 30 per cent of the original mortgage amount.
- Don’t pay for more prepayments than you need (only 18 per cent of Canadians use lump-sum prepayments in any given year). But, just as importantly, don’t underestimate the prepayment options you’ll need. Prepayment flexibility can help you reduce a mortgage penalty, or it can save you interest in the event of a cash windfall.
9. When can I make these prepayments?
The best lenders allow you to make prepayments any time during the year, in multiple instalments.
10. How much can I increase my ongoing payments each year?
Most mortgages let you increase your ongoing payments by 15 to 20 per cent each year. Some go up to 100 per cent and/or offer double-up payments.
11. What payment frequencies do you have?
- Examples include monthly, bi-weekly, weekly, and semi-monthly.
- Accelerated payments (like “accelerated bi-weekly”) are the equivalent of making one extra monthly payment per year. RBC Mortgage Specialist Jennifer Bissonnette notes: “A 25 year amortization can be reduced to 22 years simply choosing accelerated bi-weekly payments instead of monthly.” Being mortgage-free three years sooner will cost you just $59 more every two weeks, she adds. That’s on a $300,000 mortgage at 3.69 per cent with a 25-year amortization.
12. Can I break my mortgage any time I want?
- Most lenders let you pay a penalty and get out of a closed mortgage early. Some no-frills lenders only let you out if you sell your property. Some don’t let you discharge your mortgage at all, until the term is up.
- You’ll almost always pay a rate premium for an “open” mortgage with no penalties. If you plan to keep the mortgage for more than six months, you’re often better off choosing a lower rate and paying the penalty to get out early (if needed).
13. If a mortgage penalty applies, how do you calculate it?
- Fixed rate penalties are usually three months of interest or the interest rate differential (IRD), whichever is more. Variable-rate penalties are typically three months of interest based on your current rate.
- Penalty calculations based on posted rates (i.e. rates higher than the rate you actually pay) can sometimes be several thousand dollars more expensive. This method is common at most large banks, and is their single greatest weakness. If you want to compare penalties, try some sample calculations using each lender’s online penalty calculator.
- Some lenders get tricky. For example, instead of a standard three-month interest penalty based on your current rate, some lenders charge three-month interest penalties based on posted rates. Others charge interest rate differential penalties when three-month interest charges normally apply. A few even ding you with 12-month interest penalties or penalties equal to three per cent of your balance. Avoid such mortgages unless the rate savings is significant.
14. Can I port my mortgage to a new property to avoid penalties?
- Don’t underestimate your odds of moving. Look for good porting flexibility, especially if you’re young, need job mobility and/or have a growing family.
- Some lenders let you port, but not increase. That forces you to pay a penalty if you buy a pricier house and need more financing.
- Note that credit unions typically prevent porting across provincial lines–a problem if you move out of province.
- If you have a line of credit attached to your mortgage, make sure you can easily port it as well and keep your rate.
15. How long do you give me to port my mortgage?
- The longer the better. At least 60 days is preferable. Some lenders make you close your old property and new property on the same day, which can be unrealistic.
16. Do you deduct interest from my penalty rebate if I port my mortgage and my old and new house don’t close on the same day?
17. If I break the mortgage early, can I use my unused prepayment privileges to lower the penalty?
- Some lenders restrict you from using your prepayment options for this purpose, if you do so within 30 days of discharging the mortgage. Some lenders, like RBC, automatically apply unused prepayment privileges to lower your penalty when refinancing–a cost-saving feature.
18. If the mortgage includes cash back, how much of that cash do I have to repay if I break the mortgage early?
- Usually it’s a pro-rated amount but some lenders make you repay 100 per cent of the cash back, even if you break the mortgage one day early.
- Have your mortgage adviser calculate your “effective rate,” including the cash back. That tells you how much of a rate premium you’re paying for the cash.
19. Is there any restriction on when I can refinance?
20. Can I increase my mortgage at any time, at fully discounted rates, and without paying any penalty?
- This is vital if you need to refinance or buy a more expensive home.
- Some lenders have a policy of charging penalties, or not giving you the best rates when you increase your mortgage.
21. Can I extend my mortgage term at any time without penalty, and at fully discounted rates?
- This is useful if rates drop and you want to blend your rate with the new lower rate (which lowers your payment). It’s also key if you’re past the middle of your term and you want to mitigate the risk of higher rates at renewal.
- Beware of lenders that let you “blend and extend” but then bake a prepayment charge into your new mortgage rate.
22. Is your mortgage readvanceable?
- Readvanceable mortgages let people with at least 20 per cent equity re-borrow principal that they’ve previously paid off. This feature usually involves a credit line linked to your mortgage. Readvanceables are good low-cost sources of funds for investment opportunities, a small business, renovations and so on. Readvanceables also let you pre-pay your mortgage without the fear of not having cash on hand in an emergency. Some people even use them as an alternative to a contingency fund.
- There are two types of readvanceables: manual (where you must apply to re-borrow paid-down principal) or automatic (where every principal payment is instantly available to you if you need it).
23. Can I roll in my refinance or switch costs to the new mortgage?
24. Does your variable rate mortgage have any restrictions?
- Some variable-rate mortgages prevent you from porting or blending your rate, prevent increases and have fewer prepayment privileges.
25. Can I fix my payment so that it doesn’t move if rates increase?
- If so, and rates rise, more of your payment goes to interest. If rates fall, less of your payment goes to interest. Note that most fixed payment variable mortgages have “trigger rates.” If prime rate increases so much that it exceeds the trigger rate, the lender will boost your “fixed payment.”
26. How fast does the lender increase rates when prime rate rises?
- Some lenders, like ING, adjust their variable rates every three months, which keeps your rate lower longer. (This delay works against you if rates drop)
- A few lenders offer capped-rate variables with a ceiling on how high your rate can go. These are usually a bad deal if you do the math.
27. Can I convert my variable rate to any of the lender’s fixed rates, at any time?
- Remember, you’ll rarely get the best fixed rate when you convert. Moreover, it’s impossible to successfully time interest rates over the long run. For those reasons, do not go variable to save money in the short run, hoping to lock in “at the right time.” Variables are a long-term strategy.
28. If I convert my variable rate to a fixed rate, will I get the absolute lowest rate the lender offers for that term?
- Typically you won’t. Lenders know you’d have to break your mortgage and pay a penalty. Most use that as leverage to offer merely average rates on conversions.
29. Can I split the mortgage into different parts?
- “Hybrid mortgages,” as they’re called, let you lock part of your mortgage into a fixed rate, or various fixed rate components, while the other parts may float at a variable rate. The purpose is to diversify your rate risk.
- If you pick a mortgage with both long and short terms, remember that the lender may not offer you the best rates on the renewal of your shorter term. It knows you’d have to pay a penalty to get out of your longer term, making you less rate sensitive.
30. Can you offer the amortization I want?
- Some lenders have minimum amortizations (like 18 years) while a handful of others still offer amortizations up to 35 years (assuming you have 20 per cent-plus equity).
31. Does the lender let me check my balance and remaining amortization online? Make prepayments online?
- Major banks and large non-bank lenders (like First National, Street Capital and the big credit unions) usually have the best online access.
32. Is the lender a bank or credit union with branches?
- Nowadays you can fully service your mortgage online or by phone, but some people still like a branch presence.
- Almost all lenders link to your chequing account to automatically withdraw mortgage payments and make prepayments. So it’s no longer inconvenient to separate your mortgage and banking.
- There are over 300 mortgage lenders in Canada. Don’t fear small lenders that you’ve never heard of.
33. Do you offer early renewals at your best discounted rates with no fees or penalties?
- A 120 to 180 day early renewal can potentially reduce your rate risk. But beware of lenders that try to create false urgency and lock you into a “limited time” offer well before your renewal date.
34. Do you offer an all-in-one style mortgage where I can combine chequing, savings and my mortgage into one account?
- Doing this can save interest as your spare cash lowers your mortgage balance, thus reducing the amount used to calculate your interest.
35. If I sell my house, can the buyer assume my mortgage?
36. If I get a one-year fixed, can it be converted to any of the lender’s fixed rates, at any time?
- Only a handful of lenders offer this option, which gives you variable-rate type features without committing to a long term.
37. Can I skip a payment if needed? If so, how often and under what circumstances?
- “Payment vacations” can be handy in emergencies. But some lenders require that you make an equivalent pre-payment first. Remember that skipped payments aren’t free. You still have to make all payments eventually, and interest accrues in the meantime.
38. Do you pay profit sharing on my mortgage?
- Available only at credit unions who rebate a small portion of your interest paid. You can access these funds only after a vesting period, which can last 3-7 years or more.
39. What default insurer will insure my mortgage?
- Default insurance generally applies if you have less than 20 per cent equity. When you switch lenders with an insured mortgage, you must ensure that the new lender accepts that insurer’s mortgages. CMHC and Genworth allow you the most flexibility when switching lenders.
40. If I purchase creditor life insurance through you, can I port that insurance to a new lender without having to requalify and lose the premium I’m paying on my current mortgage amount?
- Insurance premiums go up as you age, so you want insurance that’s not tied to one lender. That way, you can keep your premiums as-is on your original mortgage amount, even if you change lenders.
- If you don’t have portable creditor life insurance and get sick, your pre-existing condition may not be covered by the new lender’s insurer.
41. Will you pay my appraisal fee?
- Appraisal fees are usually $225 to $325, but can be significantly more based on location and property-type. There is usually no appraisal cost if your mortgage is insured.
42. Do you have any processing fees?
43. Do you have any cancellation fees?
44. How is the mortgage compounded?
- Semi-annual compounding costs you less than monthly compounding.
45. Do you charge “reinvestment fees” on top of the penalty if I break my mortgage early?
46. Do I have to pay legal (aka. mortgage registration) fees?
- Most lenders cover this cost on switches where the loan amount, loan-to-value and amortization are not increasing.
- A few even pay legal fees on refinances, but the rate is often higher than you can get elsewhere.
47. Is the mortgage a “collateral charge” mortgage?
- Collateral charges help you avoid paying legal fees to refinance with your lender. But they also make it potentially more expensive to switch institutions at maturity. The reason: most lenders only pay switch fees on “standard charges,” not collateral charges.
- Some collateral charge lenders register your mortgage for 100 to 125 per cent of your property value. That lets you borrow more if your property value rises. The tradeoff: It prevents you from securing anything else against your property, like a second mortgage.
48. If I switch my mortgage to you, will you pay my old lender’s discharge fee?
- Very few lenders do this, but it can’t hurt to ask.
49. Do I have to pay title insurance if I switch my mortgage to you?
- The answer is commonly yes, but some lenders don’t require title insurance, or they will pay it for you. It can be $150 to $300 or more.
50. Will I pay a higher rate if I’m self-employed and cannot prove my income in the traditional manner?
51. Does the mortgage come with free banking or significant discounts on other financial products?
- Unlike days gone by, you no longer need to bundle financial products to get the market’s best mortgage rates. Nor do you need a “special relationship” with your banker. Simply shopping around and negotiating will get you the same mortgage discounts 99 per cent of the time.
52. If I switch lenders and have a mortgage and line of credit, will the lender charge me a separate discharge fee on both the mortgage and line of credit?
53. If I need bridge financing to cover the gap between the purchase of my new home and the sale of my old home, what rate and fees will you charge?
- Also ask how long the bridge lasts. 30 days is typical.
54. Will I pay an extra fee if I break my open mortgage within 12 months?
55. If I have a problem with my mortgage, who do I call?
- Large mortgage providers like banks often have live chat or 24-hour telephone support, all tracked and recorded in case you have a problem later.
- Large lenders also have systems that enable multiple agents to work on your file. This yields faster service if your main contact is unavailable.
56. Will I get a dedicated mortgage adviser, or talk to someone different each time I have a mortgage question?
- You should always have the email address and direct number of your primary mortgage contact.
57. How long do I have to wait on hold to speak to my mortgage adviser? What are his/her hours?
58. Will my mortgage adviser contact me annually for a mortgage check-up?
- This service ensures that your rate is still competitive and that your mortgage type still makes sense for your changing needs.
59. What are your qualifications as a mortgage adviser?
- How long have you been a mortgage adviser? (The more experience, the less chance for costly mistakes. Look for two years minimum experience.)
- Do you specialize in mortgages or are you a generalist who sells many financial products but is a master of none?
- Have you closed over $10-million of financing in the last 12 months? (That’s a minimum rule of thumb for professional mortgage advisers.)
- Are you the right mortgage adviser for me? (Read this)
60. Given my lifestyle and savings, will you be honest with me about whether I can truly afford this mortgage?
- Just because a lender approves you doesn’t mean you can safely afford the payments. Moreover, alternative down payment options may not be worth the trade-offs.
61. What methods will you use to help me pick the right term?
- Proper term selection saves you way more than small rate differences, almost every time. Find an adviser that does more than glibly quote industry research or ask if you can “sleep at night” with a variable rate. At a minimum, your adviser should compare the estimated interest cost of various terms, given sample rate increases over the next five years.
62. Will you help me stress test my mortgage?
- Be sure you can afford your mortgage if rates jump 2 to 3 per cent.
63. What mortgage strategies will you provide to help me retire faster?
- Your mortgage can be used as a key financial planning tool to accelerate your savings, create future equity and build your investment portfolio.
Note: This checklist assumes you’re a qualified borrower who’s getting a mortgage on his/her primary residence, with provable income and decent credit. If this doesn’t reflect your scenario, other important questions will apply.